Thanks Andrew. I was at the summit back in June, a great event and it was nice to recap on your speech just now. This belief that speech directly affects third party behaviour is so widely believed and I can even remember Starmer reiterating it in parliament. What I don’t understand is the absence of pushback on this (apart from you of course)! 🤷🏼♂️
Hmmm. I don't know Andrew. I think stirring people up is definitely a thing. It's not the *only* thing, but it is a thing. I mean that is why people give political speeches, and make them as rousing as possible. They don't do it because it has no effect on people. They do it because has a profound effect on the audience. I'm not sure what this body of literature is your referring to when you say speech has no effect on people's actions. Speech has an effect, it can instigate revolution, or inspire them to keep calm and carry on. If there is an environment of charged debate on a topic, probably yes that will agitate people who are already crazy sufficiently that they might act. Disentangling exactly what speech was the cause is of course not possible.
Now, I'd suggest that's not a reason to censor people, it's a reason for more speech. But of course it matters what people say and what they write. Of course it influences other people's actions. That is why we do it.
The argument wasn't that the mass media environment in general inspired this guy, it was that Rupert Lowe did. Honestly I think that could be exactly what happened, although unless the perpetrator reported that there's no way to know. Or even if he did report it. As I say I don't see it as a reason to censor, but I don't see any need to be in denial about the power of political speech either.
I've written all about this at length in my books to explain. But, in short, no there is no evidence whatsoever that speech has a direct causal effect on listeners so as to remove their agency. In fact, all the evidence proves the opposite.
I will try to read it in the library. I’m interested in this claim it seems very, very doubtful. “no evidence for direct causal” … I mean, “direct causal” is a tricky one when it comes to human behaviour.
Well, this strikes me as quite doubtful in truth, and difficult to establish either way experimentally in a way that would get past an ethics committee. But the AI gave me this
which suggests a relationship in the Rwandan genocide. Well first it said "Formally, let M represent exposure to particular media content and A represent a behavioural outcome. A causal effect exists if: \[P(A\mid do(M=1))\neq P(A\mid do(M=0))
\]"
But then it gave me the Rwanda thing when I asked what the fuck it thought it was talking about.
I remember having a debate with a media effects expert on BBC radio, who was making the case for censorship. Even she had to admit there was zero evidence that people act on cue based on the words they hear.
Agency simply isn't diminished via propaganda. We're not robots.
But Andrew there is a huge gulf between "people act on cue" and "words have no effect" and anyway the question is orthogonal to the issue of censorship.
Advertising has a huge effect, that's why people spend money on it. People don't act "on cue" but their behaviour is changed. There is almost no facet of human thought or behaviour that is mono-causal. But what people say to us obviously does change us and change the likelihood we will act. We have agency, but this is not the same as being uninfluenced.
Censorship tends to be a bad idea for other reasons, which e.g. Mill discussed at length in "On Liberty".
To some degree people do have a responsibility for what they say if they are deliberately seeking to hurt other people. For example confidence tricksters. It is complex, but they are mostly edge cases where speech should be curtailed and mostly free speech works best to keep things stable and free, even if some political speech does have negative effects. The effect of censorship tends to be worse.
Thanks Andrew. I was at the summit back in June, a great event and it was nice to recap on your speech just now. This belief that speech directly affects third party behaviour is so widely believed and I can even remember Starmer reiterating it in parliament. What I don’t understand is the absence of pushback on this (apart from you of course)! 🤷🏼♂️
The political class generally hold beliefs about liberty that the public do not consider remotely acceptable. I've no idea how we bridge that gap.
Me neither!
I look forward to listening, Andrew! Currently in Cairo today. Jordan tomorrow. Home in a few days.
I do appreciate your thoughts.
Thanks!
Thanks for this excellent analysis, Andrew
I suppose the Denton's advice about no debate also feeds into this
Have cross posted
https://dustymasterson.substack.com/p/pay-it-forward
Dusty
Hmmm. I don't know Andrew. I think stirring people up is definitely a thing. It's not the *only* thing, but it is a thing. I mean that is why people give political speeches, and make them as rousing as possible. They don't do it because it has no effect on people. They do it because has a profound effect on the audience. I'm not sure what this body of literature is your referring to when you say speech has no effect on people's actions. Speech has an effect, it can instigate revolution, or inspire them to keep calm and carry on. If there is an environment of charged debate on a topic, probably yes that will agitate people who are already crazy sufficiently that they might act. Disentangling exactly what speech was the cause is of course not possible.
Now, I'd suggest that's not a reason to censor people, it's a reason for more speech. But of course it matters what people say and what they write. Of course it influences other people's actions. That is why we do it.
The argument wasn't that the mass media environment in general inspired this guy, it was that Rupert Lowe did. Honestly I think that could be exactly what happened, although unless the perpetrator reported that there's no way to know. Or even if he did report it. As I say I don't see it as a reason to censor, but I don't see any need to be in denial about the power of political speech either.
I've written all about this at length in my books to explain. But, in short, no there is no evidence whatsoever that speech has a direct causal effect on listeners so as to remove their agency. In fact, all the evidence proves the opposite.
I will try to read it in the library. I’m interested in this claim it seems very, very doubtful. “no evidence for direct causal” … I mean, “direct causal” is a tricky one when it comes to human behaviour.
Well, this strikes me as quite doubtful in truth, and difficult to establish either way experimentally in a way that would get past an ethics committee. But the AI gave me this
https://academic.oup.com/qje/article-abstract/129/4/1947/1853091
which suggests a relationship in the Rwandan genocide. Well first it said "Formally, let M represent exposure to particular media content and A represent a behavioural outcome. A causal effect exists if: \[P(A\mid do(M=1))\neq P(A\mid do(M=0))
\]"
But then it gave me the Rwanda thing when I asked what the fuck it thought it was talking about.
I remember having a debate with a media effects expert on BBC radio, who was making the case for censorship. Even she had to admit there was zero evidence that people act on cue based on the words they hear.
Agency simply isn't diminished via propaganda. We're not robots.
But Andrew there is a huge gulf between "people act on cue" and "words have no effect" and anyway the question is orthogonal to the issue of censorship.
Advertising has a huge effect, that's why people spend money on it. People don't act "on cue" but their behaviour is changed. There is almost no facet of human thought or behaviour that is mono-causal. But what people say to us obviously does change us and change the likelihood we will act. We have agency, but this is not the same as being uninfluenced.
Censorship tends to be a bad idea for other reasons, which e.g. Mill discussed at length in "On Liberty".
To some degree people do have a responsibility for what they say if they are deliberately seeking to hurt other people. For example confidence tricksters. It is complex, but they are mostly edge cases where speech should be curtailed and mostly free speech works best to keep things stable and free, even if some political speech does have negative effects. The effect of censorship tends to be worse.