Discussion about this post

User's avatar
charles cawley's avatar

Although I am no fan of Ayn Rand, she did get it right about left and right being no better than two gangs squabbling over which one was to get the spoils. Orwell appeared to have agreed as Winston was tortured by O'Brien, declaring Nazis and Communists, for all their protestations were the same, solely interested in power for its own sake. ('Power is power')

The dull dispute about whether he was left or right denies that his view evolved to settle shortly before his death, after completing 1984. Disillusionment can be most fundamental- seeing how Soviet interests exploited volunteers happily executing those who did not conform. The brutal Utilitarianism behind ideology's prime objectives of survival and spread must have come as a shock. Then a bullet, putting the cherry on the cake.

Orwell's work may belong in literature. Astonishingly, despite being banned in most authoritarian and ideological regimes, his is still absent from university politics courses. That's how far we have fallen. Echos of presence, written or in films, can be wonderful to hear.

On a business visit to Japan I visited a seaside town south of Tokyo, in a way a mini version of a cross between Atlantic City and Blackpool, solely to feel the presence I had seen in a film called Tokyo Story. I searched in vain for the place where the old couple, abused by their children, looked out over the City wondering how it was possible for people to find their way around such a vast place.

Thank you. You reminded me of then, their presence and echo.

No posts

Ready for more?